When mom met my Renee's father, he appeared charming, caring, and romantic. He appeared to have good intentions towards her and he willingly accepted the fact that she had a lot of baggage-- me, plus all the rest of her drama and history. A few months into their relationship and he was already living with us, so our small, one-bedroom apartment in the ghetto of Fordham Road, went from holding just two people to squeezing three. Little time went by before his temper tantrums unleashed like hot lava out of an active volcano. There was no satisfying his needs, requests, and demands. He wanted to track her every move, and demanded her every bit of attention at all times, all places. Even attending work became limited because God-forbid there wasn't a hot, freshly cooked meal waiting for him at the table when he got home. Eventually, all this verbal aggression became more physical. He set rules for her to follow, including no going out without his permission, no calling her family, no calling her friends, no talking to anyone about anything, and always telling him where she was at, at all times. Even when she followed the rules, he would still find a reason to beat her, coming up with any excuse for why she deserved it. I never seen anyone get beaten so bad- I was scared I couldn't save her.
By the time I was six, his routine beatings had become a norm in my house, and she eventually had no contact with the outside world, even when she was outside. I was told not to talk about any of it at school, or to anyone else, and I never did. Mom became pregnant with Renee, and the summer right before she was born, he dragged us on a trip to Colombia with him. The trip was nothing but business for him. He was a drug dealer and he needed to cover up some tracks he had over there or work-out some more deals, I suppose. Going into the airport, security wouldn't ever thoroughly check a child, so he found it very useful if I had accompanied them to Colombia, that's how I ended up going. In the bathroom at the airport, my mother stuffed stacks and rolls of bills into my pants. I knew I couldn't ask what it was for, so I kept my mouth shut and didn't complain. I got through security just fine, and for the rest of the plane ride, I had to sit uncomfortably with money shoved down my pants.
We stayed at his family’s home in Colombia and it appeared to be one huge party when we first arrived there. All the men had loaded guns and were shooting at a brick wall located in the back of the house. There wasn't really a bathroom, or comfortable beds, and somehow everyone had to squeeze themselves into rooms since there wasn’t much space. The roof didn’t actually appear to be a roof at all, and most of the rooms had no doors for privacy. It was overcrowded and uncomfortable. My duration there is now very blurry due to the fact that I've been trying to repress such memories ever since I was there. I recall being there for a few weeks, and after a few days I warmed up to the little kids there and made friends. Many mornings I remember waking up to him beating my mother mercilessly, even though she was 8 months pregnant with his child. Many mornings I would be in hysterics and scream for help and his entire family would just look at me like I was delusional or possessed. Many mornings I sat there completely hopeless and frightened that my only sibling would probably die right there and then. There was nothing I could do; we were in another country and on his territory. My mother finally realized that his aggression and violence would soon be detrimental to the survival of my sister, her, and I. Somehow, she got in contact with my godmother- who was her best friend since high school- and asked her to come to Colombia to help us escape. Being the kind, warm-hearted, caring friend that my godmother is, she came with the quickness.
My mother arranged an appointment to get her hair done at a salon not too far away from where we had been staying. The plan was for him to drop us off, and pick us up after 2 or 3 hours, and then continue on with the day's plans. Luckily, he didn't realize my mom had another agenda, secretly. My godmother met us at the salon an hour after he had left us there. They spoke to the owner of the salon who was working that day, and explained to her our situation and the owner agreed to keep her mouth shut about our whereabouts. We got in a cab and headed far out into another town. We stood the night in a small cheap hotel, until they could figure out how they’d get me back into the United States without a passport. We left all our clothes, luggage, and belongings back at where were originally staying; it'd be too obvious to try and pack those things and bring to a "hair appointment." Shortly after our disappearance, he noticed we were gone when he returned to the salon to check up on us, and saw we weren't there. He questioned the owner about our whereabouts, but she gave out no information. She then paid the price for her silence at a high cost. He shot and killed her eldest son, who had come out from the back of the salon to defend her and ask him to leave... I didn’t find this out until years later.
Though we arrived back to New York City safely, it would only be a matter of time before he came back to the city and found us again. School started in early September, and my sister was born a healthy child, thankfully. Things only seemed to get worse because he never forgave her for escaping the way she did. He started following my mom everywhere she went in order to assure himself that she would not try to escape again. Every morning, she would drive me to my Catholic elementary school and he’d be just a few feet behind us in his car, watching her walk me into the school. One day in particular, that I know I’ll never forget was when she dropped me off at school late. My school, being a religious and private school, was very strict on attendance and every time a child was late, the parent had to sign a sheet and document the reason for the child’s lateness. My mother was in the middle of signing me in late at the security desk, and suddenly he came rushing in the building, screaming and accusing her of something that wasn’t true. Somehow, in the midst of all his yelling, he found a metal fold-up chair and threw it at us and threatened to kill us and pulled out his fully loaded gun that he always had with him, right there in the school. The security guard quickly rushed us to the principal’s office for safety and my mother was in hysterics. The principal called the police for us and he was arrested only for a few days. When he came back out, the beatings got even worse. My mother couldn’t go out at all, and it even resorted to me getting hit and slammed around several times by him. I called 9-1-1 numerous times and he still found a way to come back. After all those times, I remember locking myself in the bathroom with the phone in my hands, wondering, "What am I calling 9-1-1 for, if no one is going to save me?"
After that incident at school, I was required to go to counseling twice a week at school. They’d sit me down and ask me questions about what was going on at home and how I was feeling. I didn’t want to think about how I was feeling and I didn’t want to think about what was going on at home. I just wanted to be a normal kid, who colored and played and made friends. Much of that year, I was a quiet student who didn’t speak or participate in class. My teachers thought I needed “special attention” because I wasn’t keeping up with the work, and I couldn’t concentrate in school; I was depressed and the only solution I found was to keep quiet and repress my feelings- it was what I was told to do after all. After school, I would go home to watch Disney movies all day and all night, just wrapping my mind in something other than what was going on in my life and in my house. I later on found out that I was removed from the school and not allowed to return for the third grade because my family situation was threatening the lives of other students, which became a safety issue; so much for God and those who worshipped him wanting to protect me and help me.
I stopped going to counseling and I never mentioned anything to anyone at my new school of such experiences. I went on as if nothing had ever happened and tried to start anew. Finally, after several more arrests, he was caught and incarcerated for a duration of 7 years. They sentenced him to a correctional facility far out in Texas somewhere, which to me, was the best thing that could have ever happened. My mother had no more boyfriends for a long time, and though life felt much lonelier that way, it was what she needed in order to recover from such a violent relationship. During elementary and junior high school, I chose not to express the affect of what I had gone through. It always seemed much easier to pretend to be happy than to actually be happy. When I got to high school, I fell into a deep depression and suddenly all those old memories revived themselves in my mind, which led me further down in a spiral like worm-hole overwhelmed with my emotions. I grew angry at my mother, and began to idolize my father, who had finally gotten out of prison sometime while I was in junior high school.
Not knowing my father very well, I thought he was a great man, even though he went to jail for reasons I didn’t understand. Right after getting out of jail, he got a good job, a nice girlfriend, a house and a car. He taught me to play softball and basketball and took me out occasionally. Everything seemed to be perfect. Soon after moving into this huge house with my stepmother, her and I both saw the real him. Every weekend he’d pick me up from my mother’s house, take me over to his house, and then he'd hurry out to meet up with his friends for a night of drinking and partying. My stepmother made sure to keep me and her son entertained by playing board games with us, or renting movies for us to watch. Some weekends, my father would be gone the entire time, and I wouldn’t even see him except in the afternoon when he was asleep and too hung-over to do anything. I started to slowly see that he too was not perfect. Finally after one of his infamous drunken night's out, he came home around 2 or 3 in the morning with my stepmom. I heard them when they came in because he was shouting and screaming at her about something. I peaked out my room door to see what was going on, and I see my stepmom in tears, and in a flash, he punched her in the face. She fall to the floor was so loud, I was certain our neighbors heard it. I cried as I watched her cry, and my heart hurt as hers broke. It brought back flashbacks of all the times I had to sit helplessly and watch my mother get beaten down by a man. I thought he would be a different kind of man, but I guess I was wrong. It was even more heart-breaking when my stepmother and I found out he had gotten into a serious car accident that nearly killed him, his brother, and a woman who was with them. We found out the woman involved in the car accident with him was his mistress for four of the five years that he was engaged to my stepmother. Everything I thought I knew about him, everything I thought he was, began to shatter right in front of me. It was bad enough to have a mother that put me through hell with her boyfriends, and now to have two parents, who were just so broken and damaged, made me feel hopeless about my own self and future.
By the time I was 14, my father once again got locked-up and sentenced to 6 years in prison for punching a cop. There was no way I could explain the pain of my disappointment in him. He let me down for a second time, he let my stepmother down, and he let his other two children down. They too, would be fatherless just as I was, resorting only to monthly or bi-monthly prison visits.
Many nights, as a child when going through those hard times with my mother, I prayed to God with all my might to send me back my father, in hopes of him saving me. God did send me back my father, but not at all the father I imagined him to be. Not at all the man I thought he was. Many nights, as an adolescent going through more hard times on my own, I prayed to God to just save me from myself. I prayed and I prayed, I cried and I cried, I begged as if my life depended on it. I see now, that the affects of such traumatizing events and disappointment, damaged me in ways that are far too complicated to explain. Where was God all those nights I prayed and cried for his help? Why was he not there to help me? I know people say that “everything happens for a reason,” but I have come to believe that, that is not true. Things happen only according to the will of yourself and of those around you. Things happen only when choices are made, regardless if they are good or bad, and ultimately even the smallest choice, can affect the lives of others.
For those who believe in God, I am sure you have your reasons that may be so embedded in your roots that you don’t dare to question the existence of Him. I am sure at one time or another, some people may have lost faith but then miraculously regained it. Such doubts should raise questions, and questions should not go unanswered; believing that something bad and unexplainable has happened to someone or some people is because God made it so, is not an answer.
There have been several arguments for the existence of God: ontological, cosmological, teleological, and mystical experiences. I have studied and read about all of these arguments and realized that none are consistent, and all are contradictory. In terms of logic, believers refer to God with these attributes: 1) God is all-powerful; 2) God is all-knowing; 3) God is perfectly good; 4) God exists. Religious believers then forget the problem of evil: 5) Evil exists. If God is omnipotent then he is limitless in his power, wholly good, and all-knowing, then he can and would be willing to eliminate all evil with his limitless power- but yet we find that evil still exists. If evil still exists, then God must not exist. Take away one of God’s attributes, and then the problem of evil is solved. When I refer to evil, I am speaking of the unjust, unexplainable wrongs of the world- i.e. a baby being kidnapped and killed. If everything happens for a reason, and if God exists, why should a baby be killed and pay an unnecessary price? Why do innocent children get victimized or killed? Why do innocent bystanders get killed during war? These evils are not explainable and cannot be justified by saying that “God has a plan and everything happens for a reason.” Evil is a constant in this world and has existed since the beginning of time, it is a fact that it exists since we can witness it on a day-to-day basis, experience it, and even be victims of it. Some religious believers have provided adequate solutions such as: 1) Those we call evil aren’t really evil; 2) Evil is merely the privation of good, that evil in a positive sense, evil that would really be opposed to good, does not exist; 3) Disorder is harmony not understood and that partial evil is universal good (according to the Pope). According to John L. Mackie, in his argument from the Problem of Evil, he states:
“The thinkers who restrict God’s power, but keep the term ‘omnipotence,’ may reasonably be suspected of thinking, in other contexts, that his power is really unlimited. Those who say that evil is an illusion may also be thinking, inconsistently, that the illusion is itself an evil. Those who say ‘evil’ is merely privation of good may also be thinking, inconsistently, that privation of good is an evil… If the Pope meant what he said in the first line of his couplet, that ‘disorder’ is only harmony not understood, the ‘partial evil’ of the second line must, for consistency, mean ‘that which, taken in isolation, falsely appears to be evil.’”
Then there are the fallacious solutions, which include: 1) Good cannot exist without evil; 2) Evil is necessary as a means to good; 3) The universe is better with some evil in it than it could be if there were no evil; 4) Evil is due to human free will. In overall, there are inconsistencies in all of these solutions. The issue at hand is that unjustified, unexplainable evil exists and has always existed- do the victims of such evil deserve to suffer, to be traumatized, or lose their lives because “God has made it that way”, because God has a “plan”? If God knows-all and is so powerful, why create people who would commit such evil crimes in the first place? This world could have been made just fine without evil in it, but it wasn’t and so people will suffer, die, and go through unnecessary and unjustifiable experiences of evil. There is no plan, there is no reason, and no one deserves to play the victim of someone else’s unexplainable evil doings and actions. Therefore, there is no God- at least, not to me.
Along with the loss of my faith in God, I have lost faith in myself. It is now that I am 21 years old and I am just realizing that I spent my whole life feeling depressed over the trauma and disappointment that I endured as a child. I spent my whole life trying to pretend I was normal and I was fine, and that I am happier than ever. I spent my whole life lying to myself and lying to others-= putting up this image that I was so strong and can deal with anything. The truth is, I am still depressed, and I am more damaged than ever. I am broken into a million little pieces.
I have spent several years searching for that one person that I could open up my heart to and just pour out all these repressed feelings and memories. I thought I found him. He appeared caring, warm-hearted, concerned, and willing to help me fix me. He didn’t judge me and he accepted me with all my baggage, dysfunctions, and low self-esteem. It took me some time to finally crack open and pour my heart out, but the moment I handed to him all that was left of me, he went and broke it even further. My depression has extended out longer than I can handle, and I have been having the hardest time finding a way to express myself. My writing is my only constant, the only thing that won’t judge me, criticize me, feel pity for me, or take advantage of me.
When all faith is gone and all outlets have vanished, there is no one left- but me. I have come to rely on myself more than ever. These days have felt longer and colder, and all that crosses my mind hour-to-hour is, “How could I be so broken? How did I end up so alone? Why doesn’t anyone understand me?” Secretly, I have been yearning and crying out for help from my friends, but even my most straight-forwarded requests for help haven’t done much. Sometimes skulls are thick, sometimes hearts are vacant, sometimes... words don't work.
Deep down in my soul, I know my loss in faith isn’t completely shattered, but I then begin to think, “Maybe God has forgotten me.” Like others in the world who are going through their own hard times and traumatic experiences, I know they too, wonder, “Maybe God has forgotten us.”
“The Young Man came to the Old Man seeking counsel.
I broke something, Old Man.
How badly is it broken?
It's in a million little pieces.
I'm afraid I can't help you.
Why?
There's nothing you can do.
Why?
It can't be fixed.
Why?
It's broken beyond repair. It's in a million little pieces.”